which of the following is a scientific question

Smons

2 min read

·

10-02-2025

23

0

Share

Introduction:

The ability to formulate a strong scientific question is fundamental to the scientific method. Not all questions are created equal; only those that can be tested through observation or experimentation qualify as scientific. This article will guide you through identifying a scientific question, distinguishing it from non-scientific inquiries, and offering examples to solidify your understanding. We will explore what makes a question scientifically valid and how to craft your own testable questions.

What Makes a Question Scientific?

A scientific question must meet several criteria:

• Testable: The most critical aspect. It must be possible to design an experiment or make observations to find an answer. This involves gathering measurable data.

• Measurable: The results of the investigation must be quantifiable or observable. Qualitative observations can be useful but should ideally be supported by quantitative data.

• Specific: Avoid vague or broad questions. Focus on a narrow, well-defined topic.

• Repeatable: Other scientists should be able to replicate the experiment or observation to verify the results. This ensures reliability and validity.

Examples of Scientific and Non-Scientific Questions

Let's examine some examples to illustrate the differences:

Scientific Questions:

• "Does the amount of sunlight affect the growth rate of sunflowers?" This question is testable, measurable (growth rate can be measured), specific, and repeatable.

• "What is the effect of different types of fertilizer on the yield of tomatoes?" This question is also testable using controlled experiments and measurable outcomes (tomato yield). It is specific and repeatable.

• "How does temperature affect the solubility of salt in water?" This is testable through controlled experiments, with solubility measured as a quantifiable outcome.

Non-Scientific Questions:

• "Is it ethical to clone humans?" This is a philosophical question, not a scientific one. While scientific research may inform the ethical debate, the question itself is not empirically testable.

• "What is the meaning of life?" This is a metaphysical question, outside the scope of science. Science deals with the observable and testable world.

• "Which is better, cats or dogs?" This is a matter of personal opinion and preference, not a question that can be answered through scientific investigation.

How to Formulate a Scientific Question

Here’s a step-by-step process:

1. Start with an observation: Notice something interesting in the world around you.

2. Ask a "what" or "how" question: Frame your inquiry around a cause-and-effect relationship or a process. Avoid "why" questions which can be too broad or philosophical.

3. Refine your question: Make it specific, testable, and measurable. Consider the resources and time available for your investigation.

Identifying Scientific Questions in a Multiple-Choice Format

When presented with a multiple-choice question asking to identify the scientific question, carefully examine each option against the criteria outlined above. Look for questions that:

• Are directly testable through experimentation or observation
• Allow for the collection of quantifiable data
• Are focused and specific in scope

Conclusion

Understanding the characteristics of a scientific question is crucial for conducting meaningful scientific research. By following the steps outlined in this article, you can develop well-defined, testable questions that contribute to the advancement of scientific knowledge. Remember, a good scientific question is the foundation of a successful investigation. The ability to differentiate between scientific and non-scientific questions is a hallmark of scientific literacy.